|
|
Kontermann RE / Acta Pharmacol Sin 2005 Feb; 26 (2): 1-9 |
|
| ¡¡ | ¡¡ |
|
Invited review
Recombinant bispecific antibodies for cancer therapy
Roland E KONTERMANN1
Institute of Cell Biology and Immunology, University of Stuttgart, Allmandring
31, 70569 Stuttgart, Germany
1 Correspondence to Prof. Roland
E KONTERMANN. Phn 49-711-685-6989. Fax 49-711-685-7484. E-mail Roland.Kontermann@izi.uni-stuttgart.de
Received 2004-11-02 Accepted 2004-11-12
doi: 10.1111/j.1745-7254.2005.00008.x
Abstract
Bispecific antibodies can serve as mediators to retarget effector mechanisms to disease-associated sites. Studies over the past two decades have revealed the potentials but also the limitations of conventional bispecific antibodies. The development of recombinant antibody formats has opened up the possibility of generating bispecific molecules with improved properties. This review summarizes recent developments in the field of recombinant bispecific antibodies and discusses further requirements for clinical development.
Key words antibody engineering; bispecific antibody; diabodies; single-chain diabodies; tandem scFv; targeting; effector cells; cancer therapy
¡¡
Extract
Note: Please read the
complete full text with Figures and Tables at
![]()
Introduction
The concept of using bispecific molecules in therapy is based on the selective recruitment of an effector mechanism to a defined disease-related target structure. Thus, bispecific molecules serve as mediators (adaptors) between an effector and a target. A plethora of effector mechanisms can be envisaged for therapeutic applications and a large number have already been evaluated. These include the recruitment of effector molecules (e.g. toxins, drugs, prodrugs, cytokines, radionuclides), the retargeting of effector cells (e.g. cytotoxic T lymphocytes, NK cells, macrophages, granulocytes) and the retargeting of carrier systems (e.g. viral vectors for gene therapy)[1].
Antibodies are ideally suited as starting material for the construction of bispecific molecules as they normally bind specifically and with high affinity to antigens. Using different technologies, for instance hybridoma or phage display technology, antibodies can be generated against virtually any given antigen. Smaller portions of an antibody retaining antigen-binding activity can be produced by proteolytic cleavage or in recombinant form. Several methods have been developed for the generation of bispecific antibodies. Besides chemical cross-linking of two IgG molecules or two Fab or Fab' fragments, bispecific antibodies can also be produced by fusion of two hybridomas. This hybrid-hybridoma technology results in cell lines (quadroma) that produce bispecific IgG molecules. However, the production and random association of two different heavy chains and two different light chains within one cell leads to the assembly of a substantial proportion of non-functional molecules. Thus, the hybrid-hybridoma technology and also chemical methods produce poorly defined products and require elaborate purification steps to obtain defined and clinically useful material. Nevertheless, several clinical studies have been performed to analyze the therapeutic potentials of bispecific antibodies. Most of these studies were focused on the retargeting of effector cells (cytotoxic T lymphocytes, NK cells) of the immune system to tumor cells. Mostly disappointing findings were obtained from these studies[1,2]. The main reasons were the induction of neutralizing antibodies against the murine bispecific antibodies and Fc-mediated side effects, including cytokine-release syndrome, thrombo-cytopenia and leukopenia, which limited the maximal applicable dose. Further studies indicate that the induction of inflammation within the tumor, for example, the co-application of inflammatory cytokines, is essential to achieve an effective treatment. It was concluded that besides strong and selective binding to a disease-related antigen clinically useful bispecific antibodies should fulfill several require-ments[2]: They should be non-immunogenic to avoid a neutralizing immune response. They should have a defined structure and should bind monovalently to the effector cells to induce activation of the effector cells only after binding to the target cells. They should not contain an Fc-region to avoid Fc-mediated side effects. They should have a size which allows penetration into the tumor tissue but should circulate sufficiently long to induce therapeutic effects.
Recombinant bispecific antibodies
Recombinant bispecific antibodies offer several advantages over conventional bispecific antibodies made by chemical cross-linking or fusion of two hybridoma clones and can be designed to meet the requirements described above. By using only the variable domains as building blocks, recombinant antibodies lack the Fc-region of an antibody, and thus do not induce Fc-mediated effects. Recombinant antibodies are constructed by genetic means allowing for the generation of human molecules in order to reduce or even avoid the induction of a neutralizing antibody response. Human antibody molecules used as starting blocks can be isolated, for instance, from human antibody libraries by means of phage display[3] or by using transgenic mice expressing human antibodies[4]. Recent studies have shown, however, that even fully human antibodies can be immunogenic leading to the generation of human anti-human antibodies (HAHA)[5]. By identification and removal of the responsible T cell epitopes ("deimmunization") the immunogenicity risk associated with human antibodies can be further reduced[6]. These developments in the generation of recombinant antibody molecules have led to a revival in the use of bispecific antibodies for therapeutic applications[7].
A wide variety of different recombinant bispecific antibody formats have been developed over the past years[8]. Amongst them tandem single-chain Fv molecules and diabodies and various derivatives there of are the most widely used formats for the construction of recombinant bispecific antibodies (Figure 1). Routinely, construction of these molecules starts from two single-chain Fv (scFv) fragments that recognize different antigens[9].
Tandem scFv molecules (taFv) represent a straightforward format simply connecting the two scFv molecules with an additional peptide linker (Figure 1). The two scFv fragments present in these tandem scFv molecules form separate folding entities. Thus various linkers can be used to connect the two scFv fragments and linkers with a length of up to 63 residues have been reported[10]. Although the parental scFv fragments can normally be expressed in soluble form in bacteria, it is, however, often observed that tandem scFv molecules form insoluble aggregates in bacteria. Hence, refolding protocols or the use of mammalian expression systems are routinely applied to produce soluble tandem scFv molecules. In a recent study, in vivo expression by transgenic rabbits and cattle of a tandem scFv directed against CD28 and a melanoma-assocated proteoglycan was reported[11]. In this construct the two scFv molecules were connected by a CH1 linker and serum concentrations of up to 100 mg/L of the bispecific antibody were found. Various strategies including variations of the domain order or using middle linkers with varying length or flexibility were employed to allow soluble expression in bacteria. A few studies have now reported expression of soluble tandem scFv molecules in bacteria[12-14] using either a very short Ala3 linker or long glycine/serine-rich linkers. In a recent study, we employed phage display of a tandem scFv repertoire containing randomized middle linkers with a length of 3 or 6 residues to enrich for those molecules which are produced in soluble and active form in bacteria. This approach resulted in the isolation of a preferred tandem scFv molecule with a 6 amino acid residue linker[15]. At present it is unclear if this linker sequence represents a general solution to the soluble expression of tandem scFv molecules. Nevertheless, this study demonstrate that phage display of tandem scFv molecules in combination with directed mutagenesis is a powerful tool to enrich for those molecules which can be expressed in bacteria in active form.
Bispecific diabodies (Db) utilize the diabody format for expression. Diabodies are produced from scFv fragments by reducing the length of the linker connecting the VH and VL domain to approximately 5 residues[16]. This reduction forces dimerization of two polypeptide chains by crossover pairing of the VH and VL domains (Figure 1). Bispecific diabodies are produced by expressing two polypeptide chains with either the structure VHA-VLB and VHB-VLA (VH-VL configuration) or VLA-VHB and VLB-VHA (VL-VH configuration) within the same cell. A large variety of different bispecific diabodies have been produced in the past and most of them could be expressed in soluble form in bacteria (Table 1). A recent comparative study demonstrate, however, that the orientation of the variable domains can influence expression and formation of active binding sites[17]. Nevertheless, the soluble expression in bacteria represents an important advantage over tandem scFv molecules. However, since two different polypeptide chains are expressed within a single cell inactive homodimers can be produced together with active heterodimers. This puts some obstacles towards the use as therapeutic molecules as it necessitates the implementation of additional purification steps in order to obtain homogenous preparations of bispecific diabodies.
One approach to force the generation of bispecific diabodies is the production of knob-into-hole diabodies[18]. This was demonstrated for a bispecific diabody directed against HER2 and CD3. A large knob was introduced in the VH domain by exchanging Val37 with Phe and Leu45 with Trp and a complementary hole was produced in the VL domain by mutating Phe98 to Met and Tyr87 to Ala, either in the anti-HER2 or the anti-CD3 variable domains. By using this approach the production of bispecific diabodies could be increased from 72% by the parental diabody to over 90% by the knob-into-hole diabody. Importantly, production yields did only slightly decrease by these mutations. However, a reduction in antigen-binding activity was observed for several analyzed constructs. Thus, this rather elaborate approach requires the analysis of various constructs in order to identify those mutations which produce heterodimeric molecule with unaltered binding activity.
Single-chain diabodies (scDb) represent an alternative strategy to improve the formation of bispecific diabody-like molecules[19,20]. Bispecific single-chain diabodies are produced by connecting the two diabody-forming polypeptide chains with an additional middle linker with a length of approximately 15 amino acid residues (Figure 1). Consequently, all molecules with a molecular weight corresponding to monomeric single-chain diabodies (50-60 kDa) are bispecific. Several studies have demonstrated that bispecific single-chain diabodies are expressed in bacteria in soluble and active form (Table 1) with the majority of purified molecules present as monomers[19-22]. Thus, single-chain diabodies combine the advantages of tandem scFvs (all monomers are bispecific) and diabodies (soluble expression in bacteria).
Stability improvements
Stability of the recombinant bispecific antibodies under storage conditions as well as after in vivo application is a critical parameter with strong impact for clinical application. The antibody has to be sufficiently stable to allow the molecules to induce a therapeutic benefit before being degrad-ed[23]. Unfortunately, several studies showed that tandem scFv molecules as well as diabodies were inactivated under physiological conditions, with varying half-lives depending on the antibody construct tested[15,20].
One approach to improve the stability of antibody molecules is the generation of disulfide-stabilized molecules introducing cysteine bridges between the VH-VL interfaces to inhibit dissociation of the VH and VL domains. That this results in an increased thermal stability has been shown for a bivalent anti-CEA diabody[24]. A subsequent study with a disulfide-stabilized bispecific diabody demonstrated that this approach also resulted in an increase in the formation of heterodimers similar to the knob-into-hole approach[18]. However, a marked reduction in production yield was reported for this disulfide-stabilized bispecific diabody in E coli. Principally, this approach to improve stability by introducing disulfide-bonds between the VH and VL domains is applicable for any recombinant bispecific format including tandem scFv molecules.
Several comparative studies have revealed that single-chain diabodies are more stable than diabodies and tandem scFv molecules[14,15,19,20]. This is probably a result of the physical linkage of the four variable domains, similar to the improved stability of single-chain Fv fragments compared to Fv fragments[25]. A recent study demonstrated that the length and composition of the three linkers present in a single-chain diabody molecule and its dimeric tandem form had a strong influence on stability and functional activity[26]. In this study tandem diabodies composed of 10 residue long flanking linkers and a long middle linker (27 residues) showed highest stability and activity. These results emphasize the fact that modest variations in the composition of recombinant bispecific antibodies have strong impacts on their biological properties.
Improvement of pharmacokinetics
One of the drawbacks of small recombinant bispecific antibodies for therapeutic applications is the short circulation time in the body. Diabodies, single-chain diabodies and tandem-scFv molecules have a molecular weight of 50-60 kDa. This causes rapid clearance from circulation by extravasation and renal elimination with an initial half-life (t1/2a) below 30 min[20]. This is much shorter than the half-life of whole antibody molecules, which can be in the range of several weeks, due to its larger size and Fn receptor mediated recycling.
Several approaches have been undertaken to improve the pharmacokinetics of recombinant antibodies. One approach is to increase the size of these molecules. For example, this was achieved by fusion of a bispecific single-chain diabody to the IgG CH3 or Fc region via an IgG hinge[27]. A similar approach was also applied for bispecific diabodies fusing one of the two diabody chains to a CH3 domain (di-diabody)[28]. These fusions result in the formation of dimeric molecules with molecular weights of 150-180 kDa containing four functional antigen-binding sites, two for each antigen. The advantage of using single-chain diabodies for this approach is that a single polypeptide chain is expressed resulting in the assembly of defined molecules with identical size and binding activity. In contrast, the usage of two different polypeptide chains for the expression of di-diabody may cause formation of a mixture of non-functional diabody molecules produced by homodimeric assembly of two identical polypeptide chains and functional diabody-CH3 fusion proteins. Interestingly, Lu and co-workers[28] could not detect such non-functional diabody molecules in their preparations indicating that heterodimeric assembly of the two polypeptide chains is favored, at least for the described construct. Heterodimer-forming CH3 domains containing knob-into-hole structures were also used to generate bispecific antibodies by fusion of two different scFv fragments directed against HER2 and CD16 to these domains[29]. Although not tested in vivo this bispecific minibody was stable in mouse and human serum at 37 ¡ãC for several days and biologically active.
Dimeric single-chain diabody molecules with a molecular weight of 100-115 kDa can also be generated by varying the length of the linkers connecting the variable domain. Reducing the middle linker of a single-chain diabody to less than 13 amino acid residues results in the formation of dimeric single-chain diabody (tandem diabodies, tanDb) most likely with a linear arrangement of the two polypeptide chains (Figure 1)[20,21]. Similarly, reduction of the flanking linkers to 0-1 amino acid residue results also in dimeric molecules, presumably in a tetrabody-like arrangement[21]. For tandem diabodies it has been shown that this dimerization results in a four- to eight fold increase in circulation time compared to diabodies and an improved therapeutic efficacy[20,30].
The covalent attachment of polyethylene glycol (PEG) chains may represent another possibility to improve the pharmacokinetics of recombinant bispecific antibodies. Several PEGylated protein therapeutics which exhibit increased half-lives and improved therapeutic efficacy compared to their non-PEGylated forms have been clinically approved[31]. Although as yet not applied for recombinant bispecific antibodies, it was shown for single-chain Fv fragments that PEGylation could prolong serum half-life up to 200-fold[32]. In this study single reactive cysteine residues were introduced into the scFv molecules at defined positions, e.g. at the C-terminus or in the linker region. This additional cysteine residue allowed for a site-specific coupling of a single PE.G. chain without impairing binding activity of the scFv fragment.
A rather new approach is the combination of recombinant bispecific antibodies with gene-therapeutic protocols aiming at a direct in vivo expression of the antibody molecules[33]. This should result in high and constant levels of antibody molecules over an extended period of time. Furthermore, this approach obviates the need for extensive purification and characterization of the therapeutic proteins. However, one has to keep in mind that for therapeutic applications it is essential that expression is tightly controlled in order to stall expression in the event of severe side effects. In 1999 we postulated that this approach should be applicable for the in vivo production of recombinant bispecific antibody molecules[19]. In this study we show that bispecific single-chain diabodies are secreted in an active form from mammalian producer cells in vitro and are able to selectively recruit a prodrug-converting enzyme to tumor cells. Subsequently, we developed an adenoviral system containing the gene for an anti-CD3 x anti-CEA bispecific single-chain diabody. Injection of these recombinant adenoviruses into mice resulted in high-level expression of the antibody molecule over a period of several weeks[34]. The therapeutic effects of in vivo produced proteins were recently demonstrated with an anti-CEA x anti-CD3 bispecific diabody in combination with a B7-anti-CEA scFv fusion protein[35]. In vivo expression was achieved by implanting near the tumor site 293 producer cells stably transfected with the DNA encoding these proteins. After injection of human T cells, anti-tumor effects were observed in a colon carcinoma tumor model demonstrating the feasibility of this approach. Further studies are, however, needed to establish the most effective and safe protocol, including an evaluation of in vivo and ex vivo gene transfer, a comparison of local versus systemic production, identification of suitable transcriptional control elements and safe gene transfer vehicles.
Therapeutic applications
Recombinant bispecific antibodies have already been developed for a variety of different applications with potential use in cancer therapy. These applications include the retargeting of effector molecules (prodrug-converting enzymes, radio-isotopes, complement components), effector cells (CTLs, NK cells) and adenoviral vectors (Table 1), covering various therapeutic strategies, e.g. radiotherapy, chemotherapy, immunotherapy and gene therapy. In addition, recent work explored their use as intracellular bispecific antibodies (intrabodies)[36]. In one study an intracellularly expressed diabody was used to induce a functional knockout of two cell surface receptors[37]. In another study a bispecific tandem scFv with cell-penetrating abilities was applied to restore p53 wild-type function by intracellular binding to p53[38].
Most applications of recombinant bispecific antibodies for cancer therapy focus on the retargeting of effector cells of the immune system to tumor cells (Table 1). Extensive work has been done on the retargeting of cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTLs) through binding to the T cell co-receptor molecule CD3. In addition, natural killer cells (NK) were retargeted with recombinant bispecific antibodies directed against Fcg receptor III (CD16). A large variety of different target antigens have been evaluated. Most of them represent tumor-associated antigens (TAA) over-expressed by tumor cells, including CD19, CD20, epithelial cell adhesion molecule (EpCAM), epidermal growth factor receptor (EGFR), HER2, MUC-1, and carcinoembryonic antigen (CEA) (Table 1). In addition, recent focus has switched to tumor vasculature as a target structure. Targeting tumor vasculature of solid tumors has several advantages compared to direct targeting of tumor cells[39]. Tumor endothelial cells are directly accessible for circulating agents, ie extravasation of effector molecules and cells is not necessary. All solid tumors depend on neovascularization to grow beyond a few millimeters in diameter. Thus, this approach is broadly applicable. Endothelial cells are genetically stable and do not become resistant to therapy. A few studies have demonstrated that recombinant bispecific antibodies can be employed to retarget effector cells (CTLs) or adenoviral vectors to endothelial cells in vitro. These studies used endoglin (CD105) or fibroblast activation protein (FAP) as vascular targeting structures[22,40,41]. Other suitable antigens are described, e.g. vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF) receptor, av-integrins and the ED-B domain of a tumor-associated fibronectin splice variant[42], which allows these studies to be extended to other targets but also to other effector mechanisms.
Several animal studies have been performed with recombinant bispecific antibodies and curative effects have been demonstrated[10,30,35,43-45]. Most studies with anti-CD3 bispecific antibody molecules have shown that T cells need a second stimulus to efficiently lyse target cells. This second stimulus can be provided by pre-activation of isolated T lymphocytes, e g with IL-2 and anti-CD28 antibodies. Several studies developed approaches to provide this co-stimulus in vivo by co-administering anti-CD28 antibodies or B7-scFv fusion proteins[30,46]. Interestingly, one anti-CD3 antibody used for the construction of bispecific tandem scFv molecules was shown to induce a co-stimulation independent T cell response[47,48].
Other studies evaluated various combinations of recombinant bispecific antibodies with other compounds to further improve anti-tumor responses. These approaches include the co-application of anti-CD19 x anti-CD3 diabodies, anti-CD28 antibodies and anti-CD19 x anti-CD16 bispecific diabodies targeting and activating two different effector cell types and the co-application of an anti-CD19 x anti-CD16 bispecific diabody together with thalidomide as chemotherapeutic drug[49,50]. Interestingly, these studies described synergistic effects between the different compounds indicating that further dramatic improvements of the systems are possible.
Currently there is one bispecific tandem scFv molecule (MT103) directed against CD19 and CD3 in a clinical phase I safety trial for the treatment of Non-Hodgkin's Lymphoma (NHL). This antibody was shown to be very potent in destroying CD19-expressing tumor cells in vitro and in vivo in a T cell costimulation-independent way[48]. A final report of the outcome is currently not available.
Conclusions
The past decade has led to enormous improvements in the generation and application of recombinant bispecific antibodies. These molecules combine the potentials of bispecific molecules for therapeutic applications with the advantages provided by antibody engineering technologies. Although further improvements are necessary, recent studies have shown that recombinant bispecific antibodies can find their way into the clinic.
References
| ¡¡ |